Ladies and gentlemen, I have a confession to make: I am a Twilighter.
While this is not as serious as being a Twihard, I am still a HUGE fan
of the book series. I vociferously devoured each and every line of all
four books (and the online unofficial partial fifth one). I own posters
and shirts and my mother and I forced my piano-playing brother to learn
how to play “Bella’s Lullaby” (sorry, Connor).
Though I am hardly the only young girl in the world who feels this
same way, I am classified into a smaller group: I am a film reviewer.
While preparing to write this review, I was conflicted as to what I
should say about it. My critic side is ready to pounce, while my Twilighter
side is dying to voice an opinion as well. So in order to be fair to
both parts while trying to maintain certain level neutrality, I will
be writing this review as though both personalities are a person. Almost
a schizophrenic critique if you will. There will be Kathryn the reviewer
and Kat the Twilighter. First a basic background of the story
and then I will let the two have at it.
New Moon is the second installment in the Twilight series. The story
opens up with Bella’s birthday, which is also the start of the
senior year. She does not like the idea that she is growing older while
her paler-by-the-second vampire boyfriend Edward stays forever young.
During her birthday celebration at the Cullen’s, things take a
terrible turn and the next day Edward tells Bella that he and his family
are moving from Forks without her. She has lost all happiness and becomes
depressed. The only person who starts to cheer her up is the young and
buff Jacob Black. He and Bella have a blossoming friendship until the
craziest thing happens; Jacob turns into a werewolf (Bella sure can
pick ‘em). With the love of her life gone and Jacob off doing
his own wolfy-thing, Bella is alone to sulk in her sadness and try to
find away to be with Edward again.
Okay, so first off, this movie was a vast improvement from the
first film Twilight.
Yes true, but the bar is not set that much higher in this one. The
film felt so bare-boned. The plot itself wasn’t even compelling
until after Jacob becomes a werewolf. The dialog was almost as though
they let actors Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart wing it, and with
Stewart’s talents, or lack thereof, it was hard to watch.
Kristen is improving slowly. I personally never pictured her as
Bella Swan when I read the books, nor did I picture the way she portrays
Bella’s personality, but she works with what she is given. As
for Pattinson, he was barely in the movie. He is not the central male
in this book. Jacob, who is played by Taylor Lautner, showed Twilighters
all over that he is truly committed to the films. He gained almost 30
pounds for the role and I don’t mind that he flaunted it for half
the movie.
Yeah, you and a theater full of screaming girls didn’t mind. I
just had to roll my eyes each time a squeal came out. Though I must
admit, Lautner was the most convincing of all the actors in this film.
I believed everything he said and every expression he gave. He makes
a great puppy dog face.
One thing that did bother me however was the fact that they tweaked
the trip to Italy a little bit. In the book there is no fight scene
and I thought that they only added it in for spice and did not care
to stay true to the story.
Honestly, that was one of the better parts of the movie! I am glad they
added that in there to try and keep the neutral movie goers happy. You
have to remember that movie companies are just like any business and
want to make a profit.
All I have to say to them then is “don’t bite the
hand that feeds you.”
Wise words, they definitely need to remember who really likes going
to these, and that is the fans. I just feel like there should have been
a written disclaimer to the apathetic audience members that there will
be squealing, giggling, shirtless men, glittery guys, melodramatic actresses,
and molasses-speed story buildup.
Harsh, but that is what people should know going in, minus the
last one, the plot worked like the book did. It is not my favorite of
the series, but it did what it could.
Now to put me back together again!
This film is rated PG-13 for violence and action. While this installment
is a little more violent than the first, it is just fine for a 13 year-old
to see. I would recommend this movie to two people. First, the fans
of the books should go. Chances are, you aren’t even reading this
review because you have already seen it, but just in case one lost soul
still isn’t at the local theater—go now! It is something
you will definitely want to talk to your gal pals about come Monday.
Second, boyfriends. I am not saying you should go on your own, but you
will definitely earn brownie points by sucking it up and going with
your girlfriend. Granted you will witness her eyes glazing over every
time Lautner comes on the screen shirtless, but she will appreciate
that you took her nonetheless.
I give New Moon two out of five broken down motorcycles.
And I give it three out of five Ferraris.
Why an extra point?
Three words: Shirtless Taylor Lautner.
|
The Twilight saga continues with the second film, New Moon.
This generates two very different reactions. One being high pitched screams
and over exuberant elation the other being a casual, "eh, so what".
Meaning that fans of the best selling teen geared novels are so ready to
see Edward and Bella back on the screen that nothing anyone says will sway
them. For the rest of the movie fans who hold no allegiance, this review
is for you. Because at the end of the day it is a movie and you need to
know what you are getting into. Trust me.
New Moon picks up pretty much where last years Twilight left off. The characters
have grown a bit over the summer and as Bella (Kristen Stewart) returns
to High School for her senior year she is once again looking forward to
spending time with her pale faced, uber emo vampire boyfriend Edward (Robert
Pattinson). When she finds out he and his family are leaving and she will
never see him again she spirals into a teenaged vortex of sadness and sorrow.
Teen heartbreak, remember that feeling? No sooner does she find solace in
her long time friend and neighbor Jacob, lo and behold he discovers he is
actually a werewolf and can't be with her either. And you thought your senior
year dating life was bad.
This film is obviously and understandably created for fans of the books.
Those who have not read the series have little grounding in the film and
will find it shallow, poorly acted with little or no direction. The first
80 minutes of this film are atrocious. Everyone sort of ambles around with
no purpose as the story tries to unfold. The funny, comedic, vampire moments
that made the first one bearable are no where to be found. Then once the
meat of the action begins, that is Jacobs's discovery and Edwards dealing
with a higher up vampire supreme court it is almost too late. The remaining
40 minutes of the movie bring a decent bit of substance but only as a brief
setup for film number three. So just as you begin to engage the credits
roll. Again, this information is totally from the perspective and benefit
of the normal movie goer. Gauging by the constant (and I mean constant)
squeals, giggles and screams of the 12-19 year old females in the crowd,
fans of the book loved every frame.
The Twilight Saga: New Moon is rated PG-13 for some violence and action.
I will say this for the movie series they do a good job of staying away
from any form of gratuitous sex, language or teen debauchery. If anything
Bella and Edwards relationship is built on a non physical platform which
is rare these days to say the least. For you overly sensitive movie goers
do keep in mind that Jacob and his chiseled, well built, wolf brothers seem
to never have a clean shirt handy and spend 90% of the movie bare-chested
(hence the before mentioned squeals and giggles). But even they know how
to treat a young lady with respect. Sadly I give New Moon 2 out of 5 Dream
Catchers. I almost needed one as many times as I nearly dozed off. I might
watch this weekly in 45 minute TV installments but as a non book fan, the
movie just didn't cut it. Sorry Edward, that just gives you another reason
to mope around the house. So says Matt Mungle |
I can hear it. Can you? ...The screams...they haunt me! Oh wait, that's
just millions of prepubescent girls wailing for the ever so beautiful
Edward and Jacob in the new Twilight installment: "The
Twilight Saga: New Moon". Iiiiiit's baaaaaaaaack.
Fortunately for Chris Weitz, up is only direction he could go from the
first film directed by Catherine Hardwick. As a fan of the books, especially
"New Moon", my hopes were high (expectations low) for this
new Edward, Bella and Jacob saga.
However, it seems as though someone finally has a grasp and a vision
for what a teenage love story is supposed to look and feel like. I understand
why these teenage girls swoon over their beloved characters on the silver
screen. You have modern day romance, young teenage love, shirtless Native
Americans (all with 6-packs mind you), the undead and werewolves. What
could go wrong?
In the first film - EVERYTHING! In "New Moon", it all seemed
to fall into place.
As the teenage girls oohed and ahhed over the looks of Jacob (Taylor
Lautner) and Edward (Robert Pattinson), their acting was nothing to
feel giddy about. As just a movie goer without reading the books, I
am sure it came off as just another hack acting job. But to someone
who has read the stories and knows Jacob, Bella, and Edward, they all
did their characters justice. That being said, there is still that something
special missing from the acting. The passion of the characters seemed
to wane at points were I wanted it to shimmer like the sparkly chest
of Edward. Nevertheless, as a fan, not a movie analyst...I didn't care.
They all took a step up from the original.
This film, like that of "The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day",
was not made for critics, but rather their millions upon millions of
fans across the globe. So sure their acting wasn't Oscar worthy, but
this is a teenage love story involving vampires and werewolves...what
did you expect, "Pride and Prejudice"? I think not people.
My main complaint about the original film "Twilight" was the
adaptation, direction and seriously annoying distractions to include
shoddy camera work, intrusive (and just plain bad) music sound tracking
every move, and the absence of very important information and scenes
that make the story pivotal, etc, etc. The list goes on. Chris Weitz
and Martha Rosenberg took note of past mistakes and gave us a complete
"New Moon" story with apropos adaptations and suitable special
effects. Instead of rolling my eyes throughout the film and saying in
my head "WT*?!" when it came to the story, "New Moon"
actually took me through emotional ebbs and flows like a movie should
and I was sucked in. I felt anxious, nervous, sad, happy, and lascivious.
All appropriate emotions to feel during a love story of this caliber.
There was never a part to where the music (or Bella narrating) was such
a hideous aberration or where the camera work was so bouncy and unbalanced
that I wanted to walk out of the theater. They took heed to the last
review I wrote (assuming they read it - rather presumptuous of me, isn't
it?) and just let the story tell itself and gave "New Moon"
a more classic look
.
"The Twilight Saga: New Moon" like "The Boondock Saints
II: All Saints Day" is a difficult film to just give one rating
to. Critics would laugh at me and fans would say I am unreliable if
I give it just the one. So again, I am at this point of two ratings.
As a critic, I have to give it a lofty 3.25 stars. As a fan, I give
it 4.5 rock hard, six-pack abs. Remember this is a movie for the fans,
especially readers of the series. If you aren't either of those, you
will more than likely be disappointed. But fans, Team Jacob especially,
watch out! You will be more than pleased with the outcome of this film!
|